Family plans to sue over botched execution

By MARC KOVAC @ohiocapitalblog mkovac@dixcom.com Published:

COLUMBUS -- The family of a Preble County murderer who gasped for air while being executed plans to file a federal lawsuit against the state, alleging that he was subject to cruel and unusual punishment during his lethal injection.

A Dayton law firm will handle the case on behalf of Dennis McGuire's family. Ohioans to Stop Execution announced the suit Friday, the day after McGuire became the first inmate put to death using a new two-drug combination.

"Shortly after the warden buttoned his jacket to signal the start of the execution, my dad began gasping and struggling to breathe," Amber McGuire, the inmate's daughter, said in a released statement. "I watched his stomach heave. I watched him try to sit up against the straps on the gurney. I watched him repeatedly clench his fist. It appeared to me he was fighting for his life but suffocating."

McGuire was sentenced to death for the 1989 rape and murder of a pregnant woman.

Witnesses to his execution Thursday described him struggling to breath for about 10 minutes during a process that took longer than other lethal injections administered since the state restarted capital punishment in the 1999.

A log of McGuire's final moments noted that "10 mg of midazolam and 40 mg of hydromorphone were prepared and drawn into a single syringe" for use in his execution.

The actual injection was administered in about 20 seconds, but it took more than 20 minutes for McGuire to be pronounced dead.

State prison officials have offered little comment, other than noting that they are undertaking their standard review of the process.

Ohioans to Stop Execution and at least one state lawmaker are urging Gov. John Kasich to issue "an immediate moratorium" on executions, in light of McGuire's death.

"This flawed execution reinforces my belief that the death penalty is an outdated method of punishment that has no place in civilized society," Sen. Edna Brown, D-Toledo, said in a released statement. "... I believe the evidence overwhelmingly shows that the death penalty is not necessary or appropriate to carry out justice in Ohio. Our state must move towards life without parole sentencing as the appropriate punishment for the most heinous crimes."

Want to leave your comments?

Sign in or Register to comment.

  • I do NOT agree with Sen. Edna Brown - Life without parole is a sentence for each law abiding citizen to have to pay more out of their pockets to house, feed and care for such individuals as this killer!  Why should we have to pay for them for the rest of their lives.  I agree human life is precious, but he did not give one thought to raping a young woman, killing her unborn child and killing the young woman.  What were her thoughts and how long did she try to scream for help, perhaps pleading with this man.  Why do we give murders more consideration than they give their victims!!!  No wonder criminals do not value human life, they know they will probably live for many years, yet their victims lives were cut short and their families have lost a loved one prematurely.  I say, perhaps we should bring back hangings.  Let the murders suffer and maybe they would think twice before killing someone!

  • He beat and raped a pregnant young woman, slashed her throat so deeply that it severed her caratoid artery, killed her unborn child and there is some concern that he may have suffered during his final twenty minutes of life!  What about the life of the young lady, the child she carried and her husband who committed suicide within a year of her killing?  Perhaps the best way to dea with this is to not open the execution to the public and families.  He got what he deserved.  The suffering she endured was far more traumatic.